Former CAF Disciplinary Chief Slams Sanctions Over Morocco–Senegal Final

Raymond Hack, former Chairman of the Confederation of African Football’s (CAF) Disciplinary Committee, has sharply criticized the sanctions handed down following the chaotic scenes that marred the African final between Morocco and Senegal. Hack placed much of the blame on Senegal coach Pape Thiaw, arguing that CAF’s ruling was far too lenient and failed to uphold the integrity of African football.

Hack, who previously oversaw disciplinary matters within CAF, said the committee’s decision to fine Senegal $300,000 and suspend Thiaw for five matches was “incorrect” and lacked deterrent value.

“I have reviewed the CAF Disciplinary Committee’s decision, and I must be frank: I feel they have let African football down with this ruling,” Hack stated. “Everything that happened was triggered by the conduct of the Senegalese coach, who led his players off the pitch and prevented them from continuing the match. This provoked reactions from supporters and players alike—something that should never have occurred.”

Hack argued that the penalties imposed on players were equally insufficient. He criticized CAF for issuing only two-match suspensions to those who confronted the referee during a VAR review.

“Red cards should have been shown. A two-match ban is hardly significant—it’s the same as a routine suspension for accumulated yellow cards,” he said. “People forget that the coach is a role model, especially for children.”

Hack also highlighted the financial disparity between the fines and the prize money awarded to the finalists. Morocco, the champions, received $10 million, while Senegal earned $4 million as runners-up.

“Against that backdrop, a $300,000 fine is negligible,” Hack noted. “Had I been present, I would have called for a suspension of no less than six months from all football-related activities. Allowing Thiaw to participate in the World Cup is completely inappropriate and sends the wrong message—that CAF is not firm enough in enforcing discipline.”

Hack suggested that CAF’s disciplinary leadership, headed by a Kenyan official, had the authority to impose harsher sanctions but failed to do so. He stressed that CAF must act decisively to protect its image and credibility.

“CAF has worked hard to improve its reputation, but rulings like this undermine that progress. Stricter measures should have been taken against all parties involved—both Moroccan and Senegalese players included.”

Hack’s remarks underscore growing concerns about CAF’s disciplinary consistency and its ability to deter misconduct in high-stakes competitions. His intervention adds pressure on the governing body to reassess its approach to discipline, particularly as African teams prepare for global tournaments.